Seasons 1 - 5

Jan. 15, 2022

Season 2, Episode 12: Family Killer resurfaces as Professor

Millikin University in Illinois is standing by a long-time psychology professor revealed to have shot and killed his father, mother, and teenage sister years ago. James Wolcott had changed his name and moved from Texas to hi…
Jan. 8, 2022

Season 2, Episode 11: Serial Selfies

Amanda Taylor grieved for her husband Rex who had spiraled into drug addiction that led to to his suicide. Her grief quickly turned deadly, and in April of 2015, Amanda and her accomplice Sean Ball stabbed her father-in-law …
Jan. 3, 2022

Season 2, Episode 10: TikTok Leggings

Claudia brings us cold cases that were solved in 2021! 2021 may not have been the best year for most of us, but in the cold case world it has been an amazing year if you ask us! Claudia talks about 4 cases that went cold fo…
Dec. 21, 2021

Season 2, Episode 9: Secret Romance Turned Deadly on Christmas

Sameena Imam was a woman in love. By the time Christmas Eve of 2014 finally came around, Sameena Imam couldn’t help but feel a little excited. The 34-year-old was busy preparing for the Holidays that were to follow. Since t…
Dec. 17, 2021

Season 2, Episode 8: Badass for Christmas!

The Horrifying Story Of Bobby Joe Long: From Classified Ad Rapist To Serial Killer Bobby Joe Long raped and murdered at least ten women in mid-1980s Florida before he let one get away — and she helped bring him down. For thr…
Dec. 10, 2021

Season 2, Episode 7: Ursula Herrmann- Kidnapped And Buried Alive

In 1981, on her way home in a wooded area on beautiful Lake Ammersee, Germany, 10 year old Ursula Herrmann was dragged from her bicycle, kidnapped, drugged, locked in a wooden box and buried- a forest grave from which there …
Dec. 6, 2021

Season 2, Episode 6: Bicycle Accessories & George Michael

After Nicole van den Hurk’s 1995 murder case went largely ignored for more than 20 years, stepbrother Andy van den Hurk did the only thing he could think of to get the police to reexamine the matter with a DNA test: He false…
Nov. 26, 2021

Season 2, Episode 5: Junko Furuta: 40 Days Of Hell

Listener discretion is advised!!!! Junko Furuta was on her way home from work one evening in November 1988. What she didn't know was that this was her last night of her life as she knew it, before she was kidnapped, raped a…
Nov. 19, 2021

Season 2, Episode 4: A Dickens of a Mess

Get on your glad rags and pour the bathtub gin, because we're chatting about the Merry Murderesses that inspired Chicago! 😍 If you haven't seen the play, surely you've seen the movie with Catherine Zeta Jones and Renee Zellw…
Nov. 5, 2021

Season 2, Episode 3: Wooing

He didn't just love to kill his victims; Fritz Haarmann liked to bite into their Adam's apples and tear out their throats. His "love bites" earned him the nickname The Werewolf or The Vampire of Hanover, Germany. Yes, he's a…
Oct. 29, 2021

Season 2, Episode 2: The Trick or Treat Murder

The Fabiano's had everything. Including great hair. But what they didn't have was...well, trust. Because Miss Fabiano had an illegal and "abnormal" relationship with another woman. Yes, being homosexual was illegal in Califo…
Oct. 23, 2021

Season 2, Episode 1: Ring around the Rosie, but slow mo

Plagues, prostitution, burning at the stake, cannibalism and torture-none of these are topics you would talk to your child about. However, so many of the nursery rhymes we all grew up singing have such dark history that you'…
Oct. 16, 2021

Season 1, Episode 30: The Witchcraft Murder

Here we go again...it's Halloween our favorite time of the year! I stumbled upon the strange murder of Clothilde Marchand. What came out of that trial is a bizarre tale with the following ingredients: A Ouija board, witchcra…
Sept. 24, 2021

Season 1, Episode 29: Cut the Weird Shit

In 2008 a bizarre deathbed confession came from barber and self proclaimed psychic Vernon Seitz. He admitted to his psychiatrist that years ago he had killed a child. When Vernon didn't show at the barber shop several days l…
Sept. 18, 2021

Season 1, Episode 28: Must Consult a Psychic

And we are back in Claudia's home country...good ol' Germany. On March 30th, 1922, in a rural area of Germany, the Hinterkaifeck farmstead experienced some strange occurences. The patriarch of the family, Andreas Gruber. tol…
Sept. 10, 2021

Season 1, Episode 27: Something Fishy

Come fishing with us! We are investigating theories on the Arm Shark Murder of Sydney, Australia. This story makes me laugh just thinking about it...its just bananas! In 1935 Jimmy Smith's arm was found after a shark puked i…
Sept. 2, 2021

Season 1, Episode 26: Hansel und Gretel

The question that stumped the german justice system...if you want to be killed, is it still murder??? Find out today as Claudia takes us to her home country of Germany and talks about Computer Technician Armin Meiwes, bette…
Aug. 26, 2021

Season 1, Episode 25: Don't Date Carnies!

Tommy Lynn Sells killed up to 70 people coast to coast and I'm here to tell you all about it on our latest episode of Judgy Crime Girls! How did a 10 year old little girl stop him? Explicit Content https://www.ozarksfirst.co…
Aug. 19, 2021

Season 1, Episode 24: I can't afford to live there

When a member of one of Aspen's oldest and most influential families, Nancy Pfister, was found beaten to death and stuffed in her closet-the town's first murder in 30 years- residents were stunned. As the tenant of Pfister's…
Aug. 15, 2021

Season 1, Episode 23: Make out Confessions

Tune in with us! Our final episode of the Seven Deadly Sins Series is live! Being BOASTFUL is what the Zodiac was known for. While most murderers hide from the police, he would send complex coded messages made up of symbols,…
Aug. 6, 2021

Season 1, Episode 22: NO!

Richard "Iceman" Kuklinski was an unrepented murderer who killed at least one hundred or possibly as many as two hundred people during his 30 year career as a freelance hitman for the New York crime families. Sources: Wikipe…
July 30, 2021

Season 1, Episode 21: Don't huff your glue sticks

What NETFLIX doesn't tell you about Richard Ramirez, the Night Stalker! This is such an interesting case that happened during the height of the satanic panic in the 80's. #evilboots Enjoy and thanks for listening! looper.com…
July 21, 2021

Season 1, Episode 20: Fishers of Men

Teenage Amy Fisher had an affair with mechanic Joey Buttafuoco in the early 1990's. When Buttafuoco refused to leave his wife, Amy attempted to kill her and and she became known as "The Long Island Lolita." The Proffitt Podc…
July 16, 2021

Season 1, Episode 19: Tell Mom Not To Listen

Join us as we chat about our 3rd deadly sin "Greed" with Bob and Jeremy from I'm Dead Inside When Bonanno crime family don Carmine "The Cigar" Galante declared himself the so-called "capo di tutti i capis" (boss of all bosse…