Seasons 1 - 5

Oct. 16, 2021

Season 1, Episode 30: The Witchcraft Murder

Here we go again...it's Halloween our favorite time of the year! I stumbled upon the strange murder of Clothilde Marchand. What came out of that trial is a bizarre tale with the following ingredients: A Ouija board, witchcra…
Sept. 24, 2021

Season 1, Episode 29: Cut the Weird Shit

In 2008 a bizarre deathbed confession came from barber and self proclaimed psychic Vernon Seitz. He admitted to his psychiatrist that years ago he had killed a child. When Vernon didn't show at the barber shop several days l…
Sept. 10, 2021

Season 1, Episode 27: Something Fishy

Come fishing with us! We are investigating theories on the Arm Shark Murder of Sydney, Australia. This story makes me laugh just thinking about it...its just bananas! In 1935 Jimmy Smith's arm was found after a shark puked i…
Aug. 26, 2021

Season 1, Episode 25: Don't Date Carnies!

Tommy Lynn Sells killed up to 70 people coast to coast and I'm here to tell you all about it on our latest episode of Judgy Crime Girls! How did a 10 year old little girl stop him? Explicit Content https://www.ozarksfirst.co…
Aug. 15, 2021

Season 1, Episode 23: Make out Confessions

Tune in with us! Our final episode of the Seven Deadly Sins Series is live! Being BOASTFUL is what the Zodiac was known for. While most murderers hide from the police, he would send complex coded messages made up of symbols,…
July 30, 2021

Season 1, Episode 21: Don't huff your glue sticks

What NETFLIX doesn't tell you about Richard Ramirez, the Night Stalker! This is such an interesting case that happened during the height of the satanic panic in the 80's. #evilboots Enjoy and thanks for listening! looper.com…
July 21, 2021

Season 1, Episode 20: Fishers of Men

Teenage Amy Fisher had an affair with mechanic Joey Buttafuoco in the early 1990's. When Buttafuoco refused to leave his wife, Amy attempted to kill her and and she became known as "The Long Island Lolita." The Proffitt Podc…
July 16, 2021

Season 1, Episode 19: Tell Mom Not To Listen

Join us as we chat about our 3rd deadly sin "Greed" with Bob and Jeremy from I'm Dead Inside When Bonanno crime family don Carmine "The Cigar" Galante declared himself the so-called "capo di tutti i capis" (boss of all bosse…
July 8, 2021

Season 1, Episode 18: Coke & Conversation

Serial killer Jerry Brudos: The Shoe Fetish Slayer wins the prize of being most notorious for the second deadly sin, Lust! Have some fun with us and hold onto your paperweights! SEVEN DEADLY SINS SERIES Aboutserialkillers.bl…
July 2, 2021

Season 1, Episode 17: I'm a real boy!

THE SEVEN DEADLY SINS SERIES: 1. Gluttony: Joe Metheny, the serial killer who made his victims into hamburgers will haunt your appetite for years to come! Don't ask him what's for dinner... ranker.com allthatisinteresting.co…
June 24, 2021

Season 1, Episode 16: Richard Simmons meets Gertrude

Upon first glance, Paige Birgfeld was a hardworking single mother of three who juggled multiple odd jobs to make ends meet. But an investigation into the 34 year old twice divorcee's disappearance from Grand Junction, CO in …
June 11, 2021

Season 1, Episode 15: Send us Flowers!

Anatoly Moskvin is our buzz this week! Russian professor and genius historian hides 26 girls mummified to look like dolls in his apartment and we detail every step along the way... Don't miss this insane story about this man…
May 28, 2021

Season 1, Episode 13: Pasty Legs

Dive into The Girl in the Box with Andrea this week! This story covers an "unsolved" murder as well as an AMAZING survivor story! Meet Colleen Stan...the girl that was trapped in a coffin for seven years. Sources include: ht…
May 21, 2021

Season 1, Episode 12: #icutyou

Claudia discusses Indiana serial killer Larry Eyler who murdered a minimum of 21 teenage boys and young men. Also known as the highway killer, Larry would leave bodies on the side of the road and even dismember them...disclo…
May 14, 2021

Season 1, Episode 11: Aqua Net

Andrea covers the Music Box Murder...An unnerving gift and a DNA profile solved a 25 year old cold case for the murder of Lisa Zeigert! Sources: "Who is Gary Schara?" -Stephanie Barry on Masslive.com and an article by Lori L…
April 15, 2021

Season 1, Episode 7: Hobby Lobby

Andrea covers her favorite murderer, Ed Gein! A polite, quiet man, that kept to himself and had several hobbies that included digging up corpses of over a dozen women and made things out of their remains. His horrific murder…
April 8, 2021

Season 1, Episode 6: If I untie her she runs away!

Claudia covers serial killer Herbert Baumeister, also known as the I-70 stranger! He found his victims at gay bars in the Indianapolis area. He took them back to his place, Fox Hollow Farm, drugged and raped them before kill…
April 1, 2021

Season 1, Episode 5: What you don't know about WATTS

Andrea covers what Netflix did not tell you about the Watts family murders first hand from a family friend and what YOU can do to take action! dailymail.com; Murderpedia; Denver Post; LiveAbuseFree channel YouTube The Proffi…
March 25, 2021

Season 1, Episode 4: We're Here to Murder You

Claudia gives us gruesome details about a local Fort Wayne serial killer...did you know Charlie Brandt? Dive in with us! The Proffitt Podcast The podcast that shows you tips & strategies to create content with confidence! Li…
March 18, 2021

Season 1, Episode 3: It's Not Me, It's You.

In December of 2005, a surprised motorist stumbled upon a torched Jaguar in the middle of a Las Vegas desert...in the trunk was 28 year old Melissa James. The Proffitt Podcast The podcast that shows you tips & strategies to …
March 10, 2021

Season 1, Episode 2: Pleading the Fifth Twenty Five Times

Claudia discusses the rampage of Aileen Wuornos and her seven victims. Also, we cover how her house is haunted! Stay tuned and thanks for listening! The Proffitt Podcast The podcast that shows you tips & strategies to create…