Seasons 1 - 5

Dec. 17, 2022

Season 3, Episode 30: The Killer in the Rain

78 years ago, fast growing Fort Wayne, Indiana was paralyzed when young women started turning up murdered, all thought to be victims of a Killer in the rain. No one was above suspicion in a string of violent deaths of local …
Dec. 7, 2022

Season 3, Episode 29: Sharon "Sarah" McCully and Lauren McCarty

Austin, Texas: On December 10th, 1984 Sharon "Sarah" McCully dropped her husband, John, off at work after picking him up for lunch. Sarah was off that day and said she wanted to do some early Christmas shopping and she'll se…
Nov. 30, 2022

Season 3, Episode 28: Melanie McGuire- The Suitcase Killer

Three suitcases washed ashore along the Chesapeake Bay in May 2004, each suitcase contained different body parts of a man. The man was identified as ex-Navy William "Bill" McGuire. Police quickly followed the bloody trail of…
Nov. 23, 2022

Season 3, Episode 27: The Osborne Family Murder

Claudia is talking about the horrific murders of the Osborne Family and it happened right here in Fort Wayne, IN...literally in our backyard. When Daniel Osborne didn't show up up for work at the local paper, the News Sentin…
Nov. 18, 2022

S 3, E 26: The Tylenol Murders Part 2

Find out who the mysterious man was that the police were searching for, what was his past, and what linked him to the crime! We recommend that you listen to Part 1 first. Thank you for listening! Sources: https://medium.com/…
Nov. 9, 2022

S3, E25 Tylenol Murders Part 1

In 1982, healthy people were dying with absolutely no symptoms. Waves of panic spread across the nation as it became known over the counter medication had been tampered with. This unsolved case sent chills up my spine! Stay …
Nov. 2, 2022

Season 3, Episode 24: Brittani Marcell

In September 2008, 17 year old Brittani Marcell was brutally attacked in her home. Brittani’s mom came home to find a man standing over Brittani holding a shovel and her daughter was horribly beaten. The man was able to esca…
Oct. 26, 2022

Season 3, Episode 23: Skinned Alive: The Horrific Murder Of Katarzyna Zowada

*This episode may be disturbing for some listeners. Discretion is advised* In November 1998, 23 year old University student Katarzyna Zowada disappears without a trace from Krakow, Poland. A couple of months later, a tugboa…
Oct. 23, 2022

S 3: E 22, “The Family” Cult

One of the few cults led by a female was known as “The Family” founded by Anne Hamilton-Byrne in 1963 in Melbourne, Australia. "The Family" combined Christian, Hindu, and New Age ideas with the use of psychedelic drugs and t…
Oct. 13, 2022

Season 3, Episode 21: The Watcher House and the Broaddus Family

It’s Spooky season, yall and todays case totally creeped us out. In 2014 Derek and Maria Broaddus bought their $1.3 million dream home in Westfield, New Jersey and were excited to move in….until a series of disturbing and th…
Oct. 5, 2022

S 3, E 20: Indiana Gunness Murder Farm

Belle Gunness loved her men, but not nearly as much as she loved her money. Peek into the grisly crimes of the Indiana "Black Widow" serial killer that lured men from all over with her "triflers need not apply" classified ad…
Sept. 28, 2022

Season 3, Episode 19: Kidnapped in broad daylight:The Denise Amber Lee Story

On January 17, 2008, 21 year old mother of two, Denise Amber Lee, was abducted from her home around 2PM, with her children present, and would be dead by the end of the day. Five 911 calls were made, including one by Denise h…
Sept. 21, 2022

Season 3, Episode 18: The Mysterious Death of Lauren Agee

Lauren Agee was a 21-year-old student from Tennessee who was found dead in a cove off Centre Hill Lake after attending Wakefest on the weekend of July 25th to 27th 2015. The official story is that, after consuming a large qu…
Sept. 14, 2022

Season 3, Episode 17: Andrew Urdiales: from Marine to Serial Killer

In September 1992, 19 year old Jennifer Asbenson survived an attempted rape and murder from an elusive serial killer, Andrew Urdiales. What she didn't know was that he had already killed three women before her between 1986-1…
Sept. 7, 2022

Season 3, Episode 16: The Disappearance of Angela Velzka-Lawrence

This hometown case was sent in to us by our long time listener and friend of the podcast, Jessica. Many of those involved at the time were minors and because of this, it was not highly publicized. This episode contains Expli…
Aug. 31, 2022

Season 3, Episode 15: The disappearances of Ashley Pond and Miranda Gaddis

WARNING: this episode contains abuse and sexual assault. Listeners discretion is advised! When Ashley Pond disappeared on a chilly morning in January 2002 on her way to the bus stop, the investigators first thought she had r…
Aug. 24, 2022

Season 3, Episode 14: The Mysterious Deaths of the Jamison Family

On October 8, 2009, Bobby Jamison, 44, his wife Sherilynn, 40, 6-year-old Madyson, and their dog Maisy, loaded their pickup truck, headed into Oklahoma’s San Bois mountains, and were never seen alive again. Four years later …
Aug. 19, 2022

Season 3, Episode 13: Jeffrey MacDonald Part 2: Victim or Murderer?

We conclude our discussion about the MacDonald case. Does the evidence show that MacDonald killed his family? Or is an innocent man in prison? Let us know what you think! SOURCES: http://themacdonaldcase.com/ https://macdona…
Aug. 17, 2022

Season 3, Episode 12: Jeffrey MacDonald Part 1...Victim or Murderer?

In the early morning hours on February 17th, 1970, dispatchers at Fort Bragg, N.C. received an emergency call from Jeffrey MacDonald, who reported a stabbing at his residence. When Military Police arrived at the residence t…
Aug. 11, 2022

Season 3, Episode 11: The Ghost of Angela Samota

In 1984, Angela Samota was a 20 year old college student in Dallas, TX. She had her whole life ahead of her...until she didn't. On October 12th, Angie was brutally attacked and found lifeless in her bed. Detectives began a c…
Aug. 3, 2022

Season 3, Episode 10: The Gitchie Manitou Murders

On November 17th, 1973, five teenage friends entered the Gitchie Manitou State Preserve Park to sit around a campfire, smoke and play a little guitar, but only one of them lived through the night to tell how her friends were…
July 27, 2022

Season 3: Episode 9, Peter Masden the Trophy Husband & Human

Danish engineer and mad inventor Peter Masden was intriguing to Swedish journalist Kim Wall. He was inspiring to many and well known for his rockets, space lab, and multiple submarines. But her story of a lifetime turned int…
July 20, 2022

Season 3, Episode 8: Daniel LaPlante: The Creep Inside The Walls and Convicted Murderer

In late 1987 Daniel LaPlante brutally killed 33 yr old pregnant Priscilla Gustafson and her two young children. However, it was not this case that made him (in)famous, but the crimes he committed before the murders, althoug…
July 13, 2022

Season 3, Episode 7: Frances Lee plays Shenga

Meet the woman that inspired Murder She Wrote's Angela Lansbury! During a time when women didn't have any place among police, Frances Lee became known as the mother of forensic science and was famous for her crime solving an…