Subscriber-only episode In 1976, Circleville, OH residents mysteriously began receiving threatening and sometimes sexual letters. All of them were postmarked from nearby Columbus, without a return address, by an anonymous w…
An Unlocked Episode of Judgy After Dark! The incredible story of 11 year old Terry Jo Duperrault. She was not only the sole survivor of her family's murder, but she spent four days alone on a tiny raft in the middle of the o…
Subscriber-only episode The Doodler is one of San Francisco's most infamous cold-case serial killers — although not for lack of leads. The Doodler is believed to have killed at least six and up to fourteen men in San Francis…
Subscriber-only episode Mark Gerardo and Jennair Cox met in Fort Wayne, IN and fell for each other as young teenagers. The pair would go on to marry, but like many marriages, it was not without struggles. Shortly after relo…
On August 8, 2017, Tanja Ebert, 23, mysteriously disappeared in Australia after her husband said they had an argument. Tanja, her husband and their two small kids lived on a remote outback property and supposedly Tanja just …
Subscriber-only episode What started as a fun Eastern European vacation ended in a family’s worst nightmare and remains a mystery to this day. 28 year old Lars Mittank, from Germany, joined his friends last minute on a trip …
Subscriber-only episode Mary Vincent was picked up when hitchhiking at just 15 years old in CA, not realizing she would soon become the victim of a brutal attack that would include rape, torture, and the maiming of her arms.…
Just three years ago, FedEx turned their heads when Morgan Fox filed a complaint with HR regarding a co-worker that was stalking her. Jason McDermitt had taken her phone, downloaded private information including intimate pic…
Subscriber-only episode On June 29th 1978 Hogan’s Heroes Star Bob Crane was found murdered in his apartment in Scottsdale, Arizona. After his death several details about his personal life were revealed to the public which on…
Subscriber-only episode Iowa paperboy Johnny Gosch vanished in 1982, then the chilling sightings of him began. The 12-year-old was one of the first in the nation to have his photograph placed on a milk carton. His parents ad…
January 6, 1982 was one of the coldest nights of the winter, with temperatures dipping down to negative 20 degrees, when two young women vanished from the popular ski resort town of Breckenridge, Colorado within 3 hours of e…
Subscriber-only episode When Hans Schmidt was a child in Bavaria, other kids played sports, but he liked going to the slaughterhouse to watch animals being killed. " Ich seh gern blut !" he'd say ("I like to see the blood").…
Subscriber-only episode In 1984 Deborah Wilson's body was discovered on campus at Drexel University in Philadelphia, and investigators had four main suspects. The case was a tough one, and sat cold for eight years although t…
You have a chance to help other women and also help solve this murder. This episode contains a detailed interview with both her mother and father, Tom and Erika Pillsbury. On April 16th 2023, Mercedes Vega was captured on CC…
Subscriber-only episode On October 6, 1983, the bodies of Andrea Scherpf and Bernd Göricke, two German backpackers, were discovered in a wooded area west of Chetwynd, British Columbia, Canada. Both victims had been shot in t…
Subscriber-only episode Johnny Frank Garrett was accused of murdering a Catholic nun who lived across the street from him. On Halloween in 1981, Sister Tadea Benz was the victim of a horrific murder in her seemingly safe St.…
Did you know San Antonio, TX is one of the most haunted cities in America? A hotel would not be complete without a ghost story attached to its history. The story goes that in February of 1965, a young man named Walter Emeric…
Subscriber-only episode Today’s case is very scary and heart wrenching. We’re gonna be talking about what happened to Adriane Insogna and Leslie Mazzara, both 26. This case happened on Halloween night in 2004 and it’s truly …
Subscriber-only episode Sally met Pastor John White in 2006 on Halloween in Mount Pleasant, MI. Over the next six years, John did a fantastic job of fooling her as well as the congregation. He had been fantasizing about havi…
For being an incredibly smart man, Issei Sagawa had disturbing unspoken fantasies from the age of just seven years old. He longed to eat people...and that is exactly what he grew up to do. Renee Hartevelt, his college friend…
Subscriber-only episode On the evening of Sept. 12, 1980, Rose Burkert, 22, and Roger Atkison, 32, checked into the Amana Holiday Inn along Interstate 80 near Williamsburg, Iowa, for a romantic getaway….but they never checke…
Subscriber-only episode Was it an accident, murder, or a conspiracy to hide an unimaginable truth? Over 40 years ago, on October 23rd, 1981, Kurt Sova went to a Halloween house party with a friend. The same night, he disappe…
Robert and Charlotte Hullinger, from Cincinnati, OH, formed Parents of Murdered Children after their 19 year old Daughter Lisa was brutally attacked by her ex boyfriend and died from her injuries on September 25th, 1978 in H…
Subscriber-only episode On a hot summer night on July 13, 1982, three teenagers, Raylene Rice, Jill Montgomery and Kenneth Franks, were brutally murdered in Speegleville Park, near Lake Waco, Texas. That night the area was f…
